Monday, May 10, 2010

Good Poetry?

Not all great poems rhythm. Not all great poems use big words. I could keep going, but the point is that great poetry doesn’t always seem to have much in common. In your opinion, what MUST a good poem have? What must it include, be about, or discuss?

20 comments:

  1. I tend to like poems that have a rhythm scheme. Yet there are a few poems i know of that do not rhyme that I like. So what make a good poem would have to be the way the artist not only uses his words correctly but how he delivers it. Also any good poem, by any poet, knows that metaphors and similes are key. I was also taught that a poem has no bounds and that anyone can wright anything about anything, but it is usually a basic idea to have a back up meaning because just plain out saying "I am angry" is not exiting or grabbing or whatever it takes to make a good poem. And that is what i think i takes to make a good poem.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't really care what the subject matter is of a poem as long as it reads rhythmically. It would probably be more interesting to me if read easily, had a beat, and quickly guided you to its end. I'm usually more drawn to poems that rhyme as opposed to mere thoughts and feelings on a particular subject.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't really mind poems at all. I actually like reading them. Some are sad, happy, agry, depressing, joyful, silly, maybe even stupid. However, poems are great. The one think I really look foward into a poem is having it rhym. Rhyming is great. It reminds me of a song. I love to sing so there fore i could imagine it into a song. Thats the one great thing i like about poems.

    ReplyDelete
  4. All great poems must have many different components to make it great. One thing a great poem must have is a good literal meaning and a very good deeper meaning to get a message across. A good message is key to a poem and if it is covered up by a nice soothing literal meaning it makes it that much better. Another component a great poem must have is a good rhyming scheme. I really like poems that rhyme somewhere throughout it because it gives a good feel and mood to the poem. The last thing I think a great poem must have is a good theme which sort of goes along with what I said about meaning in a poem.

    ReplyDelete
  5. All meaningful great poems must have a lot of simile's and metaphors. In my opinion all poems should show a meaning by the end of it. The poem should be able to ""move" the reader, and make them think to find out what it truly means. Most moving poems are either about life or romance. ALso, metaphors and simile's make the poem much more interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good poems must have some pattern to them. They should either have a rhyming scheme, a syllable pattern, or words that are used over and over in the poem. These different types of patterns make a poem flow, which makes it good. Having a rhyming scheme makes the poem read easy and can also add to the poems mood. Great poems also have a syllable pattern, which is where certain lines have around the same amount of syllables. This also makes a poem flow easily. Also, some great poems repeat lines or words throughout the poem. This gives emphasis to the poem and adds to its mood. Not all poems have to rhyme, but all great poems have a certain pattern that makes them great.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Personally, I like poems which convey not only a literal meaning, but also a figurative meaning. Poems with a second meaning appeal to me. For example; the poem "The Road Not Taken" by Robert Frost (http://www.wsu.edu/~wldciv/world_civ_reader/world_civ_reader_2/frost_road.html). From the first time you read it, the poem seems to only be about a traveler who is almost "looking back" on his journey and realizing the different paths he could have taken. But when you read it a couple more times, the poem displays a philosophy on life. He talks about how he regrets not being able to do everything in life, and how he is going to be unique by taking "the road less traveled" and make a difference in peoples lives by not being stereotypical.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Poetry as a whole consists of a wide spectrum of different content. For poetry to be truly great, however, requires a few standards to be met and exceeded. Poetry is about the use of verbal language, the spoken word. When great, the creative images poetry evokes are based on simplicity not complexity. The great poem uses fewer words than ordinary prose does to stimulate the human mind. The words collectively produce images and sounds, which are just as or more important than the sum of the dictionary definitions of the words on the page. Poems are expected to have deeper meaning than the letters forming words on the page. Their sights and sounds evoke "deeper meanings" for both the poet and the reader, more like a song, painting or sculpture than mere prose writing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The poems that I look at as good usually fall under a certain pattern. Usually the poems I like do not rhyme but then again some songs/ poems rhyme and I like those. I like a poem that rhymes if it has a strong theme, if the poem just rhymes and doesn't mean anything I wont like it. This also brings up another trait that a good poem should have which is an underlining theme, the whole poem should make the theme more meaningful to the reader. Good poems should also use different types of writing styles, for instance the writer should fluctuate between descriptive writing and non-descriptive, and use similes, metaphors and, analogies.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Personally, I believe that a well written and entertaining poem must contain a few things. I think that they must have a well stretched metaphor throughout the poem and a good rhythmic scheme. To me, they tend to be more interesting and a little more fun to read. They are more fun because when you read them out loud you can have a little fun with the tone and rhythm when reading the poem aloud. Extended metaphors also drag me into poems and catch my interest. I think that they area great way to show the reader how the main theme or topic of the poem compares to something that they would understand.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I believe that a good poem must contain similes and good rhythm. The first element of poetry that a good poem needs is the element of similes. Similes are a comparison using the words like or as and are crucial for the reader to understand the poem. The author of the poem knows exactly what each phrase means and how it should be interpreted. For example, if the author wrote, “The bird’s feather was blue”. The author knows this means that birds feathers were as blue as the summer sky, but the reader does not. The reader can interpret the bird’s feathers to be different shades of blue such as ocean blue or navy blue. By using like or as the poet can tell the reader what shade of blue the bird is. If the author had said, “The bird’s feathers were as blue as a summer sky”, then the reader would have known what shade of blue the feathers were. Similes explain the poet’s message to the reader so that the poems correct message can be enjoyed. I believe that in order to have a good poem it must have similes.
    The second element of fiction that makes a good poem is the element of rhythm. Rhythm is the flow of words within each meter and stanza. Rhythm allows poems words to flow which is very important in poetry. If a poem was choppy and did not flow well, it would not sound appealing to the reader. When people hear a choppy poem it makes them less likely to focus on the message of the poem. Rhythm also tends to catch the reads ears and tune in on what the poet is conveying. That is why I believe it is important for a good poem to have rhythm.

    ReplyDelete
  12. A good poem must be well written with a concise and accurate use of language. The great advantage of poetry is that it can encapsulate ideas in the minimum of words. This is one of the main distinguishing features of poetry as compared to prose.
    A good poem should be able to lift the reader out of the ordinary and give glimpses of a more illumining reality.
    I googled what makes a good poem, and found this answer. I'm putting this in my response because I couldn't agree more with the answer. The main point the answer brings up that I feel is most important, is how a poem uses the minimum amount of words to paint a picture in the readers head. To me, a poem is only good if I can truly picture myself in the poems setting just from reading it once. Thats a good poem to me.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I consider a good poem must have alot of meaning and emotion. Of course, not all poems need this to be considered good. Poems are all different and many different poems appeal to many different people but for myself I find that a poem that just seems interesting or that can make me laugh could be a good one as well. The poem would have to be well written to be a good poem. For example, it must have alot of different literary devices that can be understood easily.

    ReplyDelete
  14. To make a poem good, it must have meaning. The meaning can be simple, or it can take thought but if it's just a bunch of words scrambled together that doesn't make sense, then you can't take anything from that. A poem is usually written from emotions the poet is feeling or has felt and by writing what the feel poetically, there will be meaning. When looking at a poem it might not make sense at first but when you really analyze it and you can start to picture what is happening and you can feel the emotions then the poem is a good one.

    ReplyDelete
  15. A good poem must interpret one or more themes, expressing something that could be hard to understand so you have to give it deeper meaning, or just something on your mind. You have to go in depth with the theme. For example symbolism could make it have more depth and help the reader understand what you are expressing. Usually when you make a poem expressing your feelings, it's really good because you have a good grasp on it since your feeling it so you know how to express it. Not all good poems need metaphors or alliterations for example. You could just describe a theme or feeling with depth so that the big picture shines through. You want to catch the readers eye with creativeness, and make it understandable.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Like sanderson said, i also don't mind poems. i like them because they express feelings and emotions and you can relate to a lot of it. I just think poems need to express the emotions and paint a picture through any literary device. Sometimes the ones the make you think more and have a deeper meaning are more enjoyable to relate to real life situations. I think that symbolism is important there because it can make you think and than relate. I do like the poems that make you think, but with a real true meaning, not something strange and unordinary. I also think poems need metaphors to give it the deep meaning and similes to make it relatable. All those things make a poem deep and relatable which is enjoyable in my view.
    I also agree with others who have said the poems that rhyme are more fun so if i am in a good mood, i would enjoy those. I like poems that relate to your mood, as well.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I believe that a good poem contains many elements to it. First of all it should rhyme, when words rhyme through a poem it seems to flow better. In addition, a good poem should have a secondary meaning to go along with the literal meaning, something that makes you think. There should be some symbolism or metaphors in the poem. Those are the elements that make a good poem.

    ReplyDelete
  18. a good poem should have an underlining meaning to get a point across. its sould aslo use atleast a couple metaphors or similes to show what they are saying. event though not all poems need to have ryhm schemes most good poems do. i think to make a poem great it should have a ryhm scheme.

    ReplyDelete
  19. In my opinion, there are more things that a great poem doesn't need to have the it does need to have. Some of these include rhyme scheme, rhythm, flow, or use of syllables. However a poem can possess none, some, or all of these things and still be great. The most important thing that a poem must have is an affective message. The reader needs to walk away from the poem with it still on their mind. If a poem does not have a strong message, it does not have a lasting affect on the reader. Because of this, there is no way that a poem that does not have a lasting message/ affect on the audience it can never be considered a great poem.

    ReplyDelete
  20. i believe that poems should have their heart and soul in it. It should tell thoughts that run through the mind of the writer

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.