Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Conflict in Bread Givers

Explore one of the major differences from the novel between the Old World and the New - between tradition and individuality. What is different about their value systems?

4 comments:

  1. One of the major differences between old world/new world is how wealth is viewed in society. For example the mom was talking about how back in Russia her family was considered wealthy because they had fancy quilts, fancy tablecloths, etc. Nowadays and back in that time period to be considered wealthy you had to buy goods that were made by a machine, you had to own a big house, and wear nice clothes. Just those two comparisons show the difference of the worlds the mom and her children live in. The difference in their value systems is when the mom was a kid you could be wealthy and not own the biggest house on the block or wear the nicest clothes they could make fancy homemade things. Now all the children say things like "look how rich he is his coat must be hundreds of dollars"

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the major diffrences between the Old world and New in this story is marriage. The Father believes that his girls need to marry someone who is wealthy and can easily support his girls, and also someone who is dedicated to his religion. Father does not get along with the men his daughters bring home because some aren't religious enough and others don't have enough money. The Daughters care about love, and that drives their relationships with the men they pick out; they figure they'd rather be in love with their husband and have to work then be unhappy and be forced to marry someone who has money to support a family. This causes major fights within the family because of the Old versus the New World's way of thinking.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with gcharmont that marriage is a major difference between the Old and New world. I would like to add on to her point. Yes, the father of this family tries to match who the daughters marry like in Europe, but in America they get to choose. Their preaching father does not understand this change. Going off of that, a difference is becoming someone. Here in America, Sara, the youngest daughter, wants to be a person and something special. She wants to be heard and do what she wants and marry who she wants. Also, a difference is getting jobs and the given opportunity in America. There is so much more opportunity to have a good life and make something of yourself. At the time, the Old World was not like that at all. There was not much freedom such as choosing who you want to marry.
    Lastly, father has to realize religion is no longer everything here. He has to try to change and assimilate into the new culture.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.