Monday, November 23, 2009
Questions We Can Ask the Film
As we begin to watch a film version of the play we’re reading, it is important to understand how we’re supposed to watch the film, and what we’re supposed to be doing. We are used to passive watching, i.e. simply watching the film without too much thought. But we should be active viewers, bringing questions to the film. Explore one or more of these questions. [Example: One question is “How is this film DIFFERENT from the play, and WHY?”] Please don’t repeat ideas here.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I completely agree with the idea that viewers should be more active in films and bring questions to it. This film is going to be different from the play for a few reasons. First off, movies tend to be less exciting and tend to not to bring the audience into the excitement that a play generally does. Plays are scripted but they can have a few parts where they run around and just get the crowd into it and get them up and dancing, but movies don't ever do that. This specific film will be different from the play because the play will probably more lifelike about how the african americans were treated. Plays also pause sometimes to show what the character was thinking or feeling and movies cannot do that. I believe that you get more detail from a play rather than a film.
ReplyDeleteToday when we watch old films, they can seem so “corny” to us. Many years ago, films were a lot like plays. In plays, acting seems more dramatic. The actors move around the set more and the tone and inflection of their voice is more dramatic. They often wear showy costumes and bright makeup that have more of an impact from the stage. The performance is live in front of an audience which can have a positive or negative influence on the performance. In movies, the set usually seems more realistic. The actors show their emotions through facial expressions and are less theatrical with their hand and body motions. The camera travels with the characters and uses close-ups to show emotion. The film can be edited, so any mistakes can be deleted. The actors in the film have to wait until the film is released to find out if people enjoyed it. In a play, the actors generally know right away how the audience felt about it. These are just a few things that are different between plays and movies.
ReplyDeleteWhen we watch a film that was made based on a book some people tend to not read the book and just watch the movie. Reading the book before the movie may seem inconvenient to them but can make all the difference in what the film means to them. A film is different from a play in many ways. One way is the film may be based off the book but the director of the film puts his own spin and opinion into the movie changing sometimes the authors original meaning. Another difference is in a book you imagine the whole storyline i.e. how a character looks, what the setting looks like, etc. By watching a movie this conception of how you imagine these things may be let down by how the director imagined them causing you maybe not to feel the same way. There are many other differences between movies and books but these are just a few important ones. Although there are more you get the drift of where i am going that the people who only go to see the movie won't get or understand the whole story.
ReplyDeleteWhile watching the movie adaption if "A Raisin In the Sun" you should ask yourself " do you understand it more once you have seen the movie or does it confuse you some what." This is because when I was reading "A Raisin In the Sun" I got lost at some points to do with the fact that the vernacular writing confuses the understanding of sentences. Also, the vernacular writing when I was reading it usually didn't flow as well as it should or will once I see the movie adaptation. While watching the movie you should also tell yourself that this isn't of our time period and things were different back then so just realize that things were different and when watching the movie try to put your self in that time period's shoes.
ReplyDeleteWhen you watch the film “A Raisin in the Sun” you should ask yourself several questions. One, do the characters in the film match the way you perceived them when reading the book. This is important because if they don’t match it becomes hard to follow the story. Next, is it easier to follow the story when reading or watching? In other words do you miss the narration. Does not knowing what the character is thinking affect the way you comprehend the plot.
ReplyDeleteIt is important to be active viewers while watching "A Raisin in the sun" the movie because there are usually differences you discover between the play and the book. It's important to be active viewers because sometimes reading the book you can easily get side tracked, meanwhile in a play your usually more entertained which makes you more attentive. Hence, being more alert to what is going on in the play, you might pick up some parts that you missed in the book. Also sometimes a scene would make more sense by watching the play because you have a visual picture of the way they say things, so you know the mood of the person better, and that can help you understand a part better.
ReplyDeleteDuring the film, "A Raisin in The Sun" we do have to be active viewers because watching the play and reading the book both help you learn more about what is happening to this family during this time periode. It is important to ask questions while watching the film not just sitting there and watching it for the sake that we can watch something in class. During the film we have to ask questions like what is happening to this family and why isnt it happening to anyone white? Why are they getting treated so differently if we are the same people back then? Everyones equal no one should be treated differently because of their race. We can also ask during this film, " What is it trying to tell us?" If we really found out what the film was trying to say we would understand it so much better and think about how important this family was in the past. Lorraine Hansberry honestly must have wanted people to know how she spent her life, and she wanted it to change. Feeling how Lorraine probably did during this periode of time would be horrible because her family also got treated differently for being black. While I watch this film I would be concentrated on the film so I can learn more about it and find out why its so important.
ReplyDeleteWhen watching the film of Raisin in the Sun the viewer should concentrate on answering these questions: Does the information and context of the book match up with that of the movie's?, Is there a meaning through the movie?, and If so, what?. Many movies based on books are not exactly the same as written. The directors may decide to add a more exciting action thrilled part of the movie in to grab the audience's attention. During the movie, you need to key into this and think whether or not certain things were found inside the book. Maybe a young frail boy was portrayed as a tall built young adult in the film. Characters are also influenced.
ReplyDeleteThe other thing was to think of a theme or a moral to the film. If there is one it could help us better understand the movie and what it is trying to tell us. Maybe the director is trying to get a message to the audience. For Raisin in the Sun Hansberry could have wanted the viewers to connect with Ruby and her stressing situation over her low income of money.
To be honest, I really can’t think of any other example of in-direct racism because everyone before me already gave the reasons. But I disagree with what Matt said, how today there are no acts of racism because we want to be a better country and all of that. It’s true that today the people of America are trying to become a better nation by stopping racism, but the truth is that no matter how against racism some people are, there will always be some who are for it. I truly agree the most with what Andrew said though, how a Mexican immigrant competing for the same job as an American would not get the job. This is a horrible act, but it is true and is occurring everyday. So this one example here proves that there are acts of in-direct racism occurring throughout the world.
ReplyDeleteWatching the old movie of the raisin in the sun helps understanding the text. It helps understand it because it gives you a better feeling and emotion of the reading. It also helps to watch the old one because the time it is being filmed is also when the story is set so the actors have a better understanding of what the characters really feel. Unlike if you had actors from the present day it would be harder form them to become the characters when it would be harder for them to relate.
ReplyDeletewhen you read any type of play or story you most of the time paint a picture in your mind of what is going on. when you get to watch a movie it's like the painting has come alive. though sometimes the movie can disappoint because you have painted a different picture and it was not what you were expecting to see. sometimes its that your imagination has formed you to think outside the box which can make reading more interesting and when you get to the movie it's not what your expecting. thats why it's important to pay attention during a movie and not be passive because sometimes the movie can help finish the picture you were thinking of or it gives you a new way of looking at it. the movies tend to differ from the stories they are based on and it's just another way to look at what you've read and it helps you use your imagination.
ReplyDeletei agree that people should be more involved in fimls the same way they are in plays. i also believe that thye should see the film after they read the book. doing both, you can compare how much the two were alike. i like the movie because you can actually see the ideas and everything. your reading is very important, and you can understand well. however, when you watch a film, you get to SEE whats going on.
ReplyDeletewhat i said above should be placed in the other blog, not this one.
ReplyDelete