Monday, November 9, 2009

Our Response to Genocide

If genocide is occurring in another country, what should our response be? A) Leave it be. It’s not our problem. B) We can go in, but we aren’t required to. C) We are required morally to stop evil like genocide. D) A different answer.

If you are going to agree with someone, you need to add something and not simply repeat his or her words.

15 comments:

  1. I choose D:
    I feel that the first world countries should use their power to put an end to the genocide that is happening around the world. They need to recognize the signs of genocide and not wait until it is actually happening to do something. Yet, they should not rush in. Just as the genocide was set up systematically, the disassembly should be systematic also. You can not charge in, you need to arrange things so you know they will go in your favor. During the Holocaust, the Red Army rushed the camps in plain sight, this gave the Nazis enough time to evacuate the prisoners and get rid of the evidence. If we were to deal with one today, I think we should spread our troops around their bases of operations where the genocide is occurring. That way they cannot run, they would have to give up at some point if they were surrounded. If they didn’t give up by that point, the armies should keep making the perimeter around the buildings smaller until you were close enough to breach the buildings and extract the personnel responsible. Once they knew that the prisoners were safe, they would move onto the next area, and make adjustments to the perimeter in accordance to the situation. If the third world countries worked together to eliminate the genocide, they would get better results than just one country going in.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I choose C:
    First world countries as a whole have enough wealth and power to stop a genocide in any third world countries. You cannot leave the genocide alone and look at it like because it isn't happening to you, it's none of your business. This is because the race, religion, or ethnicity that is the victim and trying to be wiped out can't help themselves. They need someone else's help. By the time they realize their people are in trouble it's already too late and the leaders of the countries have a systematic plan thats already working. Once the people fall into this plan, they cannot escape. A first world country could have enough troops ready to go in and stop it and if the countries band together, they could erase the issue before it gets to the point of people being killed. As we said in class, if you saw the people getting killed and put into death or work camps right in front of you, say the town over, you would try to stop it. Just because Genocide happens and is happening right now in Darfur, and it is far away doesn't mean anything. We still need to try to help the people when they can no longer help themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that we are required to help somewhat to a genocide that we know is happening. But i don't think we should just unload tons of soldiers because then it'll cost a big price to stop it. I think we should have limits to helping like only send a certain amount of soldiers out so that it doesn't get out of hand. I strongly suggest sending our share while the genocide is discovered young so that it will be easier to stop; if we send in soldiers when the genocide has been occuring for a long time then we will stand no chance with only a little amount of support. I think we should only help if we think we can make an impact when it is just forming to put a stop to it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Genocide is a very touchy subject in all countries. The United States should be involved, and so should other countries if the country that is undergoing genocide is having a lot of trouble with stopping it. Countires shouldn't put themselves in danger by helping out, but we should still try our best to stop it. If we were going through genocide, I would of course want other countries to help out. It isn't their complete responsability; they don't have to take it into their hands completely. Genocide is never something anyone wants to talk about, and let's just hope it will never happen in the United States.

    ReplyDelete
  5. If genocide is occurring in another country, we can go in, but we are not required to. We should go in when we feel we could stop the genocide. Sometimes genocide cannot be stopped with our army alone. If we were to go in in this case, it could cause a decrease in our army. In a case like this, I think we should not go in because it many not provide any help. Also, going into war with another country is expensive, so if it is too hard to stop, going in would not be a good idea. If the genocide seems like it is able to be stopped, expense should not be a problem. Human lives are worth much more than money itself.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. If a genocide is occurring in another country, our response should be to stand ready, prepared, and cautious of any need for help or attack upon us. Although I agree with choice C, I would like to ellaborate on it. "We can go in, but we aren’t required to" is what is stated by Mr. Moccia. The way I could state this is, we should help another's country only if we believe we are economically stable and supported to do so as well as when it seems necessary for the future outcome.

    There are many genocides going on all at once. Some small some big. The United States can't be "Superman" all the time. Although the feeling of builing up alliances is great, we arent always able to budget money towards fighting a war we arent even involved in. However, when we are stable to do so and/or it is necessary we should act. Not getting involved and thinking only of ourselves, could just diminish us as a country. We would have no alliances and/or the genocide would be left on its own having the possibility of becoming something immense. It could come to a point where it would involve us. With the Holocaust, if it werent for America and many other countries Hitler would have became powerful and later moved on to seize the rest of the world. There are many different situations with different choices to be made. There isnt one exact one except for us to be cautious of the situation and maybe take the lead in helping out.

    ReplyDelete
  8. B:
    I believe any first world country should realize that it's the right thing to do and try to support a stop of genocide. Like npedalino said, "i don't think we should just unload tons of soldiers because then it'll cost a big price to stop it". We should not get involved completly, but we should support a stop. The United States should always look at it like that because we are a country of equality and indivisualism. We always say to treat others equally no matter what race, so we should take a stand and prove everyone SHOULD BE treated equally. Some countries are not as far advanced (espcially middle east). Therefore United States for one of the many countries, should support a stop to genocides.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree with B for the most part because I believe that we are required to stop any genocide that we can. There is a famous quote by Martin Niemoller that says:
    “First they came for the communists, and I did not speak out--
    because I was not a communist;
    Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out--
    because I was not a socialist;
    Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out--
    because I was not a trade unionist;
    Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out--
    because I was not a Jew;
    Then they came for me--
    and there was no one left to speak out for me.”
    We are morally obligated to speak out against all genocides. However, the actions that we, as Americans, can take are limited by international laws. We are unable to stop the genocide in Darfur because we are not at war with Sudan. To go in with a military would be a foreign relations disaster. There are other actions besides military, that can and should be taken to stop genocide. For example, we could boycott any trades with the Sudanese government until they stop killing their people.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree that we are required to stop evil like genocide, because morally we cant watch another country destroy itself that would make us inhumane. But, on the other had we are not required to end the genocide since it is their own government that is allowing this. What a first world country can do to try to end the genocide of a third world country would be to help raise money for the support of injured and for soldiers trying to defend their country. If the first world country doesn't get involved into the genocide then it is like the first world country is allowing of organizing the genocide, because without trying to prevent it we will just watch a civil war continue. Though we could sit back and watch the genocide come to a conclusion that is completely unethical an inhumane to sit back and watch innocent people die that is why a first world country could step up and help a third world country in genocide.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I choose B
    I believe that the United States, as a first world country, can go into a foreign country to oppose genocide, but we are not required to. Being a first world country doesn’t mean that we have to be the “police’ of the world. To remain a first world country, we need to keep our country’s economy strong, and using America’s resources to oppose genocide is costly. If the fight to stop genocide would cost a billion dollars, we have to consider, is it in America’s best interest? It is better for several first world countries to work together in opposing genocide. By cooperating, countries could share political responsibility and financial needs. Powerful nations working together could stop genocide. It is very difficult for one nation to accomplish international peace by itself.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Whether , and to what extent, the US should interfere in another country’s affairs is always a difficult decision. However, when you add genocide to the mix, the difficulty of the decision is magnified ten-fold because any intervention will almost certainly result in the death of US troops. Although almost everyone would agree that senseless slaughter of men, women and children is a moral outrage, the question of whether our citizens should risk lives to save others is always subject to intense debate. Throughout the years, the US has attempted to stop genocide, but the scope if its commitment appears to be largely based on its/our personal stake in the outcome and not upon the coming to the rescue of all those who are truly in need.

    For me, whether the US should intervene in another country to stop genocide presents a relatively straight forward and simple question, but nevertheless one that is impossible to answer. Are the lives of our citizens more important than those of the people who are being slaughtered. I submit, that as a society we could agree that the US should stop genocide wherever it occurs and to whomever it affects, as long as it does not involve our citizens dying in the process. There lies the dilemma. In the end, I could not send my father or brother or anyone to die for someone else and I don’t know if I would have the courage to go either.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree with Gcharmont because you cannot leave a whole country getting wiped out within seconds. It must affect you when you hear about people, thousands dieing. She makes a good point when she explains that we need to help the country out but it always ends up being too late. This is so true because so many people are dieing at one time within seconds and we need to help them, because if we were in their position we would feel that other countries should help us. In my opinion, we are required to stop anything evil like. People dieing isnt like failing a class. Today, we are actually treating genocides as if they are not important. If we dont help poor innocent people from dieing in other genocides it makes us look horrible because it shows that we dont care at all. I know so many people that would try and help the innocent people getting killed, why not try saving them? Its what you truely believe, and i believe no one should suffer if they did not do anything at all.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I choose D; a different answer. To stop genoicide WE as a whole need to make a change. not just one single person, that ends up not doing much. People have to gather and help as one. if we all help in some way i bet we can make a call and help these people in darfur thay are suffuring and dying each day. however, not only one person can do this. we have to do it as a whole for it to succeed.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm choosing A on this one. I belive that if a genocide is occuring during our time and it doesn't bother us. We shouldn't waste our hard earned money on something that doesn't effect us.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.