Edgar Allan Poe had an extremely interesting (and twisted) personal life. He was an alcoholic, never held a steady job, and married his 13-year old cousin, Virginia Clemm.
This brings up two questions. Feel free to respond to either: 1) How much should we care about an author’s personal life? Should we consider a person’s life when we read and analyze his or her writings? 2) Often writers are crazy, depressed, and have faced serious trauma. Do people need to have awful things happen to them to produce powerful literature?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
In response to the 1st question I think we should care about an authors personal life. An authors personal life is usually what they base the stories they write on. The authors feelings is what makes their stories what they are. We should also take into account when we are reading that if you notice the authors message is a very sad message then most likely he was feeling down at the time he wrote the story. So you should always think about how you think the author was feeling at the time he wrote the story
ReplyDeleteIn reply to the 2nd question;
ReplyDeleteI feel like sometimes if authors have faced serious trama throughout their lives, they are the type of authors who really make touching or rather strange stories. If an author has had depressing times, I think those are the authors that really make a story that can touch your heart. I believe the reason for that is they can relate to what they write and feel the pain a character can go through. I dont mean, though, that authors who havent experienced these situations can't write a heart touching story. I just think if you've lived it, you can write about it more effectively.
All authors do not have to experience trauma in their life time to write a powerful story, although it does help. They should have some experience, whether something traumatic happened to either a friend or themselves. This helps the writer get in touch with their feeling in what they write. It also makes the reader as if what happened in the story actually happened it real life. When the reader asks the question, "Did this really happen?," that shows that the author wrote a powerful story whether if was fictional or actually happened.
ReplyDelete1st question
ReplyDeleteUsually when finishing up a novel or story, you seem to wonder why the author wrote it. To figure this out you may have to do some research, but with new knowledge comes rewards, for instance after reading an Edgar Allan Poe story you don't know that he married his 13 year old cousin. Even though this doesn't retain to his stories it is still a good idea to research the author of a story you are reading. When reading a story while knowing background information about the author you can pick out certain parts of the story and relate them to the authors life, or experiences. This not only refers to works of literature but any art for; an artist may draw a painting from his pastor a musician may right a song about his family and where he lived. All this information is shown through there works that is why I feel that knowing the background of a writer is important.
Authors that have faced serious traumas have incredible stories. Authors that are depressed usually relate to a lot of things, they understand and know how it feels to either experience or relate to some conflicts. I belive that authors do not need to have horrible things happen to them in order to be a well author. Authors can imagine about people who do have harsh lives, they can think about how they would feel if they went through the same conflict. The only disadvantage would be that they dont honestly know how it feels. Awful things happening to you does not change if your a good author, it just means that they have a slight advantage.
ReplyDeleteIn response to question one, when you are analyzing the authors work and trying to find the meaning, you should look into their personal life because usually people write about what's going on in their life or the people around them. So if the author is depressed, their work probably wouldn't be very uplifting or humorous. It would probably be dark and give you the feelings of depression. Yet, I don't think people should ever judge an author's work based on what they know about their personal life. For instance, Edgar Allen Poe, he obviously had a pretty strange life but his writing is amazing. So if you heard people talking about Poe before you read his work it might discourage you to read it. Based on what his personal life is like, you would most likely think that an alcoholic who married their cousin who was half their age wouldn't come up with outstanding plot lines. So you should care about their personal life when analyzing a piece of work, but not when judging what to read.
ReplyDeleteWell I think that we should care about this persons personal life because it teaches you a personal lesson in it. For a writers writing to be good you must be able to feel the pain and emotion and if it comes from personal experience then yes you should want to know about his life. About his struggles because in this case it happened to make a good story and it made you think. But if a writer didn't have that then they would not be able to write such a good story and also some people use writing as a safety cushion in there lives because they get it all out and it feels good to do that. So yes they should use personal experience because it can be better than for the reader and can help the author too.
ReplyDeleteEdgar Allan Poe definately had no where near a normal life. He was an alcohlic and could never hold on to a steady job. Poe later ended up marrying his 13 year old cousin Virginia Clemm. Obviously, Poe is different then the average man. And I most certainly agree that an author's background affects what or how he/she writes. This is not always the case, but for Edgar Allan Poe he mostly sticks with one tone: a grewsome, sad feeling. As referred to before, Poe's life must have been hard on him and put a great deal of pressure on himself. Through his works you can feel the same depression he had once felt long before. Considering an author's personal life, can explain there reason for the work they wrote about. Going to an opposite side of Poe, his poem Annabel Lee is more of a playful, heartfelt piece. We can infer that the poem is written for his wife Virginia. Poe writes the poem in his view talking of his love to his wife, Annabel. However, Annabel can be related to Virginia. This is one example of how an author's life affects about what they decide to write about. Authors can have the option of writing freely and letting there mind open, but some of the time there is a reason for it. They could write about something they have observed, be involved with, or heard about. Sometimes we need to explore the possibilities to understand why the author is writing about this and what it is they are writing about.
ReplyDeletein response to the second qquestion,
ReplyDeleteI believe experiencing traumatic things does not make an author a good author. It helps because its easier to write about things that people have experienced first hand, but does not determine a good author. If a person has not experienced things that effect them personally, that does not make them a bad author. That author can still write powerful literature it just would not be as correct as the story written by the author that has experienced the event, but could still be just as powerful. So i think knowing the background of an author's life is pointless due to the fact that the author's life does not make a good story, being able to write powerful literature makes a good story.
2)In the midst of author's and their different writing skills, I think that personal experience has always had a lot to do with it. The more perplexing secrets and stories you have to tell, the more powerful and misunderstood your writing is or can be. If you have a bad personal experience, you can write about it and have other people relate, or you can twist it up and make it completely different and more sick to the mind. As did Edgar Allen Poe, in most cases. 1) The more we know about an author's personal life, the more we would know about why they wrote this, why they wrote that. If didn't know about Edgar Allen Poe's strange life, we would have just thought he was an amazing writer and leave it at that. The fact that we do know about some of his past lets us focus on him towards his writing; and how he probably did base some of his stories on real life problems he had.
ReplyDeleteIn response to question 1.
ReplyDeleteI believe that one of the true ways to discover the meanings of stories and poems writen by someone is to understand things that have happened to them or things about their personal life. This is because in many cases when you understand a persons life you may be able to understand where they are coming from and how they felt. Also, it can show one's outlook on life and by knowing things about this person you can see why they felt this way because everyone sees the world differently. Especially in Poe's case because he had quite the unique persona, you almost would need to know a few things about his life to understand how he looked at things or why he wrote them in such a way that he did. However, still today philosophers and such people who study Poe still can't figure out why he wrote the things he did and honestly, the world will never know because Poe isn't alive anymore to tell us how he thinks or feels; therefore we know what we know and his literature surely gives us room to think and question his work and even give our own mind questions about our life in some cases.
Thank you.